Principal Risks and Uncertainties
Risk assessment and evaluation is an integral part of the Group's annual planning cycle and market specific risks are evaluated as part of the annual budgeting process.
Each operating business is required each year to identify and document the significant strategic, operational and financial and accounting risks facing the business. For each significant risk, a number of scenarios are mapped out and an assessment is made of the likelihood and impact of each risk scenario. Finally, plans and processes are established which are designed to control each risk and minimise its potential impact.
The risk assessments from each of the operating businesses are reviewed with the Executive Directors and a consolidated risk assessment is reviewed by the Board.
The principal risks and uncertainties which are currently judged to have the largest potential impact on the Group's long-term performance are set out below.
Risk: Strategic
Downturn in major markets
Adverse changes in the major markets in which the businesses operate can have a significant impact on performance. The effects will either be seen in terms of slowing revenue growth, due to reduced or delayed demand for products and services, or pressure on margins due to increased competitive pressures.
A number of characteristics of the Group's businesses moderate the impact of economic and business cycles on the Group as a whole:
- The Group's businesses operate in three different sectors with different cyclical characteristics and across a number of geographic markets, as set out on page 10.
- The businesses offer specialised products and services; this offers a degree of protection against customers quickly switching business to achieve a better price.
- A high proportion of the Group's sales comprise consumable products and service contracts which are purchased as part of customers' operating expenditure, rather than through capital budgets.
- In the majority of cases the products are used in repair, maintenance and refurbishment applications, rather than original equipment manufacture.
Mitigation
The businesses identify key market drivers and monitor the trends and forecasts, as well as maintaining close relationships with key customers who may give an early warning of slowing demand. Changes to cost levels and inventories can then be made in a measured way to mitigate the effects.
Loss of key supplier(s)
For manufacturer-branded products, there are risks to the business if a major supplier decides to cancel the distribution agreement or if the supplier is acquired by a company which has its own distribution channels in the relevant market. There is also the risk of a supplier taking away exclusivity and either setting up direct operations or establishing another distributor.
In times of rapid economic expansion in activity, such as after a global recession, the lead times to supply key product can become very long.
No supplier represents more than 15% of Group revenue and only five suppliers represent more than 2% each of Group revenue.
Relationships with suppliers have normally been built up over many years and a strong degree of interdependence has been established. The average length of the principal supplier relationships in each of the sectors is over ten years.
Strength of relationship with supplier and volume of activity, generally ensures continuity of supply when there is shortage of product.
Mitigation
Actions to mitigate the risks include:
- Long term, multi-year exclusive contracts signed with suppliers with change of control clauses, where possible, included in contracts for protection or compensation in the event of acquisition.
- Collaborative projects and relationships maintained with individuals at many levels of the supplier organisation, together with regular review meetings and adherence to contractual terms.
- Regular review of inventory levels.
- Bundling and kitting of products and provision of added value services.
- Periodic research of alternative suppliers as part of contingency planning.
Loss of major customer(s)
The loss of one or more major customers can be a material risk.
The nature of the Group's businesses is such that there is not a high level of dependence on any individual customers and no customer represents more than 5% of sector revenue or more than 2% of total Group revenue.
Mitigation
Specific large customers are important to individual operating businesses and a high level of effort is invested in ensuring that these customers are retained and encouraged not to switch to another supplier.
In addition to providing high levels of customer service, close integration is established where possible with customers' systems and processes.
Product liability
There is a risk that products supplied by a Group business may fail in service, which could lead to a claim under product liability. The businesses, in their Terms and Conditions of sale with customers, will typically mirror the Terms and Conditions of sale from the suppliers. In this way the liability can be limited and subrogated to the supplier.
However, if a legal claim is made it will typically draw in our business as a party to the claim and the business may be exposed to legal costs and potential damages if the claim succeeds and the supplier fails to meet its liabilities for whatever reason. Product liability insurance can be limited in terms of its scope of insurable events, such as product recall.
During 2011, the Group settled a small claim received from a customer in respect of product failure which it was unable to recover from the supplier. However, there have been no similar claims during the past ten years.
Mitigation
Technically qualified personnel and control systems are in place to ensure products meet quality requirements. The Group has also established Group-wide product liability insurance which provides worldwide umbrella insurance cover of £10m in all sectors.
The Group's businesses may also elect not to supply products if they are not fully confident that the products will meet the demands of the operating environment.
Loss of key personnel
The success of the Group is built upon strong, self-standing management teams in the operating businesses, committed to the success of their respective businesses. As a result, the loss of key personnel can have a significant impact on performance, at least for a time.
Average age of our senior managers making up the self-standing management teams in the operating businesses is 43 with an average length of service of ten years.
As set out on page 43 the average length of service for all personnel in the Group is over five years.
Mitigation
Contractual terms such as notice periods and noncompete clauses can mitigate the risk in the short term. However, more successful initiatives focus on ensuring a challenging work environment with appropriate reward systems. The Group places very high importance on planning the development, motivation and reward for key managers in the operating businesses such as:
- Ensuring a challenging working environment where managers feel they have control over, and responsibility for their businesses.
- Establishing management development programmes to ensure a broad base of talented managers.
- Offering a balanced and competitive compensation package with a combination of salary, annual bonus and long-term cash incentive plans targeted at the individual business level.
- Giving the freedom, encouragement, financial resources and strategic support for managers to pursue ambitious growth plans.
Risk: Operational
Major damage to premises
The Group's businesses mostly operate from combined office/warehouse facilities which are dedicated to each business and not shared with other Group businesses.
Major damage to the facilities from fire, malicious damage or natural disaster would impact the businesses for a period until the damage is repaired or alternative facilities have been established.
However, the Group has not suffered any major damage to premises in recent years and in Clearwater, Florida there has been no significant hurricane activity for at least the last three years.
Mitigation
The business where the risk is greatest is Hercules in Clearwater, Florida which is most at risk from an environmental disaster caused by a hurricane or tornado. The building structure has been designed to withstand 150mph winds and a specific disaster plan has been drawn up and is regularly reviewed.
This includes:
- Backup power generator.
- Materials on hand to secure the facility.
- Communications reroute to other branches or interim locations.
- IT recovery plan using backup server in separate location.
- Regular building inspection and weather monitoring.
- Plans to drop-ship product from suppliers direct to customers.
The other businesses have also developed plans to prevent incidents, including fire and security alarms and regular fire drills. Insurance policies are also in place including property, contents and business interruption cover which would mitigate the financial impact.
However, the priority in such an event is to become operational as quickly as possible to minimise disruption to customers. Plans to ensure a quick and orderly recovery have been developed by the businesses and are periodically reviewed.
Loss of Information Technology ("IT") systems
Computer systems are critical to the businesses since their success is built on high levels of customer service and quick response. A complete failure of IT systems, with the loss of trading and other records, would be more damaging to the businesses than major physical damage to facilities.
Mitigation
Business interruption insurance cover is held across the Group and contingency plans have been drawn up in all businesses. The recovery plans differ by individual business, but will include some or all of the following elements:
- Full data backups as a matter of routine and backup tapes stored in a fireproof safe.
- Backup servers identified and communication reroute options identified.
- Service contracts with IT providers with access to replacement servers.
- Uninterruptible power sources and backup generators where required.
- Virus checkers and firewalls.
Risk: Financial and Accounting
The Group's activities expose it to a variety of financial and accounting risks, including foreign currency, liquidity, interest rate and credit. The policies for managing these financial risks, as well as the management of capital risks, are set out in note 18 to the consolidated financial statements. The principal financial and accounting risks are summarised below. The Group's overall management of these risks is carried out by a central treasury team (Group treasury) under policies and procedures which are reviewed and approved by the Board. Group treasury identifies, evaluates and where appropriate, hedges financial risks in close co-operation with the Group's operating businesses. The Group treasury team does not undertake speculative foreign exchange dealings for which there is no underlying exposure.
Foreign currency risk – Translational exposure
Foreign currency risk is the risk that changes in currency rates will affect the Group's results. The Group operates internationally and is exposed to foreign exchange risk arising from various currency exposures, primarily with respect to the US dollar, the Euro and the Canadian dollar. The Group also has operations outside the UK whose net assets are also exposed to foreign currency translation risk.
During the year ended 30 September 2011, ca. 75% of the Group's revenue and operating profits were earned in currencies other than UK sterling. In comparison to the prior year, the net effect of currency translation was to increase revenue by £0.5m and to increase operating profit by £Nil. It is estimated that a strengthening of UK sterling by 10% against all the currencies in which the Group does business, would reduce operating profit, before acquisition related charges and tax, by approximately £3.4m (7.5%) due to currency translation.
Currency exposures also arise from the net assets of the Group's foreign operations. At 30 September 2011, the Group's non-UK sterling trading capital employed in overseas businesses was £130.9m (2010: £103.1m), which represented 86% of the Group's trading capital employed. It is estimated that a strengthening of UK sterling of 10% against all the non-UK sterling capital employed would reduce shareholders' funds by £12.6m.
Details of average exchange rates used in the translation of overseas earnings and of year end exchange rates, used in the translation of overseas balance sheets, for the principal currencies used by the Group, are shown in note 28 to the consolidated financial statements.
Mitigation
The Group does not hedge translational exposure.
Foreign currency –Transactional exposure
The Group's UK businesses are also exposed to foreign currency risk on purchases that are denominated in a currency other than their local currency, principally US dollars, Euro and Japanese yen. The Group's Canadian and Australian businesses are also exposed to a similar risk as the majority of their purchases are denominated in US dollars.
Mitigation
The Group's businesses may hedge up to 80% of forecast (being a maximum of eighteen months) foreign currency exposures using forward foreign exchange contracts. The Group classifies its forward foreign exchange contracts, hedging forecasted transactions, as cash flow hedges and states them at fair value.
Inventory obsolescence
Working capital management is critical to success in specialised distribution businesses as this has a major impact on cash flow. The principal risk to working capital, is in inventory obsolescence and write-off.
The charge against operating profit in respect of old or surplus inventory is generally ca. £0.7m per year, but inventories are generally not subject to technological obsolescence.
Mitigation
Inventory write-offs are controlled and minimised by active management of inventory levels based on sales forecasts and regular cycle counts. Where necessary, a provision is made to cover excess inventory and potential obsolescence.
